The Secret, a best-selling self-help book and DVD by Rhonda Byrne suggests the following formula for success: ask, believe, and receive. The website for the book and DVD claims that many scientists and philosophers, including “Plato, Newton, Carnegie, Beethoven, Shakespeare, Einstein” all knew this secret. Perhaps. However, what is historical clear is that they each devoted the majority of their time to their craft:
· Plato spent his entire adult studying, reading, writing, and teaching. His dialogues became the foundation of Western philosophy and required time to produce by hand. Of course, Plato advised wisdom and success were produced through a different methodology: the Socratic Method.
· Newton’s scientific output was outstanding, and yet this is only a fraction of his total writing (his private journals, thousands of pages, focus more on theology and alchemy) and spent most of his hours working. Any student within the History of Science can tell you that Newton was also a very negative person, a misanthrope, and quarrelsome. He was not using ‘ask, believe, and receive’ in the same manner that Rhonda Byrne suggests. In fact, on his deathbed, he stated that his greatest achievement was that he led “the celibate life.”
· Carnegie entrepreneurial success was certainly not accidental. He worked hard and put men of vision and action in high positions, such as Charles M. Schwab. In fact, one of his better known quotations demonstrates he also believed in the Law of Action: “As I grow older, I pay less attention to what men say. I just watch what they do.”
· Beethoven, although deaf, spent countless hours composing music he could not hear. Although best known for his 9 symphonies, 138 of his works have Opus numbers, and there are over 200 shorter works without them. He was one of the first freelance composers in history as well as a musical genius.
· Shakespeare’s plays are inspired creations that clear were also works that took considerable to time to write, produce, and perform. Can one imagine the English language without Macbeth, Hamlet, A Midsummer Night's Dream, Romeo and Juliet, King Lear, or the Tempest? I am thankful that John Heminges and Henry Condell compiled the plays within the first folio so they did not become ‘Love's Labor's Lost’ and forgotten to time.
· Einstein had a day job while he conducted his thought experiments and balanced equations. In fact, in 1905, he had a dual career as he worked full-time as a Swiss patent clerk while he was also publishing in Annalen der Physik, the leading German physics journal. One paper was about the photoelectric effect and it lead to his Nobel Prize in 1921. Another proposed the special theory of relativity for which he is famous.
This suggests that ‘believe, ask, receive’ is too simplistic a model as it ignores the principle of cause and effect. The above examples clearly illustrate that Action (yes, with a capital A) is fundamental to the process. I suggest you use the LOA...not the Law of Attraction, but the Law of Action.
I would like to propose what I consider the real secret of success: C.A.R.
Conceive – It all starts with an idea. Know what you what and why you want it.
Act – Do something! As Lao Tzu said “The journey of a thousand miles begins with one step.” Create an action plan and move forward on it. Do not wait for pennies from heaven.
Receive – Results are produced through effort, not magic. The Wisdom of Paul is still true: “as you sow, so shall you reap” Galatians 6:7.
Finally, I would suggest that the success of The Secret itself used the C.A.R formula. From the excellent copy on the website to the high-quality production values of the DVD, it is clear a team of individuals were not just employing ‘ask, believe, receive” but were putting forth a real effort to make it a best-seller. The Law of Action was a very necessary component for the CD and the book to exist and then sell.